home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- The following transcript comes from a lecture made by Jerome Clark in
- Australia, sometime in September of 1991.
-
- ==========================================================================
-
- INTRODUCTION
-
- ...Much of what I am going to tell you is not true. I want to emphasise
- this much. Simply by repeating what someone has reported as true, does not
- mean I endorse it as true. What we're concerned with here is the anatomy of
- a modern legend in the making.
-
- When I know or have specific reasons to suspect that something is a
- fabrication, I'll say so. Otherwise I'll just recount stories whose
- tellers may or may not believe what they're saying. But here even the lies
- are interesting, because the liar's motives sometimes raise questions which
- bear on the larger issue of what some have called The Ultimate Secret.
-
- At the end of our exercise, we'll have few answers and many questions.
- Probably - though far short of certainly - some of these questions will
- have to do with our role as a planet and a race in a galaxy populated by
- intelligent beings with an advanced space technology - possibly.
-
- More certainly, we're dealing with another deep and human enigma, the
- mystery of the human imagination as it contemplates our place in the
- cosmos. If we are being led here by our own imagination, it has taken us
- down some strange and dark paths indeed.
-
- Whatever the truth may be at the end of the road, I can't take you
- directly to its door and drop you off there. All I can provide you with
- are brief, imperfect, vexing glances of "something" - a something that may
- be a kind of truth - literal or metaphorical - or just the lie inside the
- lie. I can, however, tell you a story which, if it is in any way a
- reflection of a cosmic reality, is going to affect all of us in the
- profoundest possible way...
-
- ...In September, 1980, shortly after William Moore and Charles Berlitz's
- book 'The Roswell Incident' was published, Moore, who then lived in
- Arizona, set out for Washington .D.C. to attend a debate at the Smithsonian
- Institution.
-
- Now, along the way, Moore did publicity interviews to plug his book. One
- of these was at an Omaha, Nebraska radio station . Subsequently, as he was
- leaving his hotel room, a receptionist in the lobby told him he had a phone
- call. The caller, who identified himself as a Colonel at nearby Offutt
- (sp) Air Force base, said, according to Moore, "We think you're the only
- one we've heard who seems to know what he's talking about." He asked if
- the two could meet to discuss matters further. Moore, who was on his way
- to catch a plane, begged off.
-
- A few days later, on his way home, Moore did a radio show in Albuquerque,
- New Mexico. On his way out of the studio, he was stopped to take a phone
- call; this one from someone who said he was from nearby Kirtland Air Force
- Base. He said " We think you're the only one we've heard who seems to know
- what he's talking about." And Moore said, 'Where have I heard that
- before?'
-
- Soon afterwards, Moore and the individual he would call 'Falcon', met at a
- local restaurant. It is believed, though Moore denies it, that 'Falcon' is
- US Air Force sergeant Richard Doty. Whoever Falcon may or may not have
- been, this first meeting would initiate a long-running relationship between
- Moore, and beginning in 1982, Moore's associate, Jamie Shandera, with
- members of a shadowy group said to be associated with Military
- Intelligence, and to be opposed to the continuation of the UFO cover-up.
- This relationship, Moore claims, continues to this day and involves
- something like thirty to forty individuals who have been given avian
- nicknames such as Sparrow, Condor and so on. Collectively they are called
- "The Birds."
-
- The story they have told Moore and Shandera goes like this:-
-
- ''The first UFO crash involving bodies of small gray-skinned humanoids,
- occurred near Corona, New Mexico, in 1947. This is "The Roswell Incident".
- Two years later, a humanoid was found alive and it was housed at Los
- Alamos, a highly sensitive installation where the Atomic Bomb was
- developed, until the creature died in the early 1950s. It was called
- 'EBE' after Extra-terrestrial Biological Entity, and it was the first of
- three the US Government would have in its custody between then and now.
-
- ''An Air Force Captain was EBE-One's constant companion. At first
- communication with it was almost impossible. Then a speech device which
- enabled the being to speak in English, was implanted in its throat. Then
- EBE-One, the equivalent of a mechanic on the spaceship, was able to relate
- what it knew of the nature and purpose of the visitation.
-
- ''In response to the Roswell Incident, MJ-12 - the MJ stands for
- 'Majestic' - was set up by Executive Order of President Harry Truman on
- September 24th, 1947. MJ-12 operates as a policy-making body. Project
- Aquarius is an umbrella group in which all the various components dealing
- with ET-related issues perform their various functions. Project Sigma
- conducts electronic communication with the extra-terrestrials, part of an
- on-going contact project run through the National Security Agency since
- 1964, following a landing at Holloman Air Force Base on April 30th, 1964.
-
- ''Nine extra-terrestrial races are visiting the earth. One of these races
- - little grey-skinned people from the third planet surrounding Zeta
- Reticuli - have been here for 25,000 years and influenced the direction of
- human evolution. They have also helped shape our religious beliefs.
-
- ''Some important individuals within the cover-up want it to end, and are
- preparing the American people for the reality of the alien presence through
- the vehicle of popular entertainment, including the film, 'Close Encounters
- of The Third Kind,' whose climax is a thinly-disguised version of the
- Holloman landing.
-
- ''At CIA headquarters in Langley, Virginia, there is a thick book
- informally called "The Bible: a compilation of all the various project
- reports.''
-
- As Moore was being fed these incredible tales, for which, it should be
- noted, not a shred of real, verifying evidence was being offered, and about
- which even Moore had doubts, he was asked to monitor the activities of a
- man named Paul Bennewitz.
-
- Bennewitz, an Albuquerque business man trained as a physicist, lived close
- to Kirtland Air Force Base. In the late 1970s, he became convinced that he
- was monitoring electronic signals which extra-terrestrials were using to
- control the persons they had abducted. Bennewitz tried to decode these
- signals and believed he was succeeding. At the same time he began to see
- what he thought were UFOs manoeuvering around the Manzano nuclear storage
- facility, in the Coyote Canyon test area, and he filmed them.
-
- Bennewitz reported as much to the Aerial Phenomena Research Organization,
- whose directors concluded he was deluded. Undeterred, Bennewitz contacted
- AFOSI agent, Richard Doty, -- the individual who as we have just noted, is
- rumoured to be Moore's FALCON -- after having been referred to him by the
- head of Kirtland's base security. Bennewitz met on two occasions with Doty
- and others from Kirtland, including Jerry Miller, a well-placed scientist
- at Kirtland, who is suspected of being another of Moore's 'Birds'.
-
- By now Bennewitz had seized upon a dark, paranoia-driven interpretation. He
- became convinced that he had deciphered the code the signals were
- conveying, and they indicated the US Government was communicating with ETs
- and was looking the other way as these ETs not only abducted human beings,
- but killed and mutilated them.
-
- What makes the Bennewitz affair so horrifying, however, is not the
- spectacle of yet another deluded UFO buff. The importance of the incident
- lies in the response of the Kirtland AFOSI office.
-
- Now, I should explain that the Air Force Office of Special Investigations,
- is the Air Force's police agency. It conducts investigations, for example,
- into security matters.
-
- AFOSI agents began a blatantly illegal counter-intelligence operation
- against Bennewitz because something he had learned really scared them. The
- electronic signals, whatever they were truly about, were quite rea1 and
- highly classified.
-
- The plot was hatched to drive Bennewitz crazy in the most commonly
- understood sense of the term.
-
- AFOSI agents went to his house and confided what they said were the UFO
- cover-up's darkest secrets. They said the US Government and malevolent
- aliens are in an uneasy alliance, that the aliens are mutilating human
- beings, whose organs they need to lengthen their lives, and that they are
- even eating human flesh. In underground bases at Government installations
- in Nevada and New Mexico, human and alien scientists work together on
- ghastly experiments, including the creation of soul-less androids out of
- human and animal body parts. Aliens are abducting as many as one American
- in forty and implanting devices which control behaviour. CIA brainwashing
- and other control techniques are doing the same, turning life on Earth into
- a nightmare of violence and irrationality. It was, as Moore would remark,
- "The wildest science fiction scenario anyone could imagine."
-
- But Bennewitz believed it. He grew ever more obsessed, and tried to alert
- prominent persons to the imminent peril. As evidence, he produced
- photographs which he claimed showed human-alien activity, but which
- dispassionate observers thought depicted natural rock formations and other
- mundane phenomena. Meanwhile, AFOSI agents were breaking into Bennewitz's
- home when he was away at work, and re-arranging his furniture, so that
- every evening he returned - inexplicably to him - to a new environment.
- Badly distraught already, he was driven even further into the outer reaches
- of paranoia. Eventually he was hospitalized.
-
- All the while, Moore was meeting with him regularly, watching his, quote,
- unquote, "friend's growing disintegration" and reporting his observations
- to his quote, unquote "Friends at AFOSI."
-
- This was not the first UFO hoax in which Richard Doty has been implicated.
- Another - going back to 1978 - involved the mailing of an apparent carbon
- copy of an offical US Air Force incident report to a tabloid newspaper.
- The incident report described an encounter with UFO beings in the atomic
- weapons area of Ellsworth Air Force Base in South Dakota. The tabloid sent
- reporters to the area to investigate, and they concluded the report was
- a hoax. At the time, Doty was assigned to the AFOSI office at Ellsworth.
- Since then, Moore has identified Doty as among those responsible.
-
- Another Doty-related hoax involved a letter sent to the Lorenzens of APRO
- and signed by Craig Wetzell (sp) recounting a UFO sighting over Kirtland
- Air Force Base. Supposedly, Wetzell had taken photographs and these were
- later confiscated by a Mr Huck from Sandia Laboratories which are located
- on the base. Wetzell is a real person who, when interviewed some time
- later, said he had had a sighting, though a less dramatic one than detailed
- in the letter, but had taken no photographs and knew nothing of a Mr Huck.
- But he had reported the sighting to Sgt. Doty.
-
- In January, 1983, a New York attorney, Peter Gersten, met with Doty in New
- Mexico. Doty swore the Ellsworth story was true. He said the government
- knows that UFOs are extra-terrestrial and [are] from 50 light-years from
- the Earth. There had been at least three UFO crashes with bodies. A
- spectacular incident, much like the one depicted in the ending of the film
- 'Close Encounters Of The Third Kind' took place in the 1960s. The National
- Security Agency is communicating electronically with ETs through a project
- Aquarius. Inside the UFO organizations, moles are collecting information
- and spreading disinformation. The most sensitive cover-up documents are
- impossible to get out of the appropriate files. Some are protected in such
- a way that they will disintegrate within five seconds exposure to air.
-
- These documents tell of agreements between the US Government and
- extra-terrestrials under which the latter are free to conduct animal
- mutilations - especially of cattle - and to land at certain bases. All of
- this is in exchange for information about advanced UFO technology. Doty
- also claimed that through the medium of popular entertainment, the American
- people are being prepared to accept the reality of visitation by benevolent
- beings from other worlds. At one point in the conversation, Doty asked
- Gersten, quoting, "How do you know that I'm not here to either give you
- misinformation, or to give you information which is part of the
- programming, knowing you're going to go out and spread it around?"
-
- In March 1983, a documentary film-maker from Denver, Colorado, Linda
- Moulton-Howe was laying plans for a show to be titled "UFOs: The ET
- Factor" and to be aired on Home Box Office, a cable television network.
- Gersten arranged for her to meet with Doty and she flew to Albuquerque on
- April 9th. Though he was supposed to meet her there, Doty was not at the
- airport, and Howe ended up calling Jerry Miller, whom she knew from an
- earlier telephone conversation when she'd asked him what he thought of
- Bennewitz's claims. Miller drove her to his house and phoned Doty who then
- arrived. Doty in turn drove her to what he described as 'his boss's office'
- at Kirtland. Asked if he knew anything about the Holloman landing, Doty
- said it happened, but that Emenegger had gotten the date wrong; it really
- took place on April 25th, 1964 -- now note, this is the _third_ date we've
- heard for this alleged event -- and it had taken place twelve hours after
- the famous Socorro landing witnessed by police officer Zamora. Military
- and scientific personnel at the base knew a landing was coming but quote
- "Someone blew the time and co-ordinates" end quote, and a quote, unquote,
- "advanced military scoutship" had come down at the wrong time and place
- to be observed by Zamora. When three UFOs appeared at Holloman at six
- o'clock the following morning, one landed while the other two hovered
- overhead. During the meeting between the UFO-beings and a Government
- party, the preserved bodies of dead aliens had been given to the ETs who,
- in turn, had returned something unspecified. Five ground and aerial
- cameras recorded this event.
-
- Doty insisted that Howe sit in a particular chair. This led her to
- believe their exchange was being recorded. At one point Doty withdrew
- several sheets of paper from a brown envelope and said "My superiors have
- asked me to show you this." She could not copy their contents, she could
- only read them and ask questions. The document didn't indicate which, if
- any, government, military or scientific agency had prepared the report,
- which was titled 'A Briefing Paper For the President of the United States
- On the Subject of Unidentified Flying Vehicles.' It did not specify which
- president.
-
- Written in a dry, bureaucratic sort of prose, it recounted the stories
- we've already reviewed: UFOs have crashed since 1949; three EBEs have been
- kept in US Government custody; through genetic manipulation aliens have
- guided our evolution and helped direct our religious beliefs; various
- ultra secret government projects have dealt with aspects of the
- visitation... Doty told Howe she would be given thousands of feet of
- film of crashed disks, bodies, EBE-One and the Holloman landing and
- contact. She could use this material in her documentary to tell the
- story of how US officals learned that the Earth is being visited and what
- they have done about it. "We want you to do this film," Howe quotes Doty
- as saying.
-
- When Howe asked why she, and not the 'New York Times' or the 'Washington
- Post' was getting this, the story of the millenium, Doty replied bluntly
- that an individual media person is easier to manipulate and discredit than
- a major corporation with expensive attorneys. He said that another plan to
- release the information through Emenegger and Sandler had been halted
- because political conditions weren't right. Over the next several weeks,
- Howe had a number of phone conversations with Doty and she spoke on several
- occasions with three other men, but did not meet them personally. Doty
- even suggested that at some point she might be able to conduct a live,
- televised interview with EBE-Three, but the current film project was to
- have an historical emphasis -- it would begin in 1949 and end in 1964. But
- if at some point Howe did meet with EBE-Three, there was no way she could
- prepare herself for the shock and fear of meeting a live being from another
- world. Doty told Howe, she and a small crew would soon be able to
- interview the retired Colonel - who was then a Captain - who had spent
- three years with EBE-One who supposedly had died of unknown causes in June,
- 1952. But first she was going to have to go through a whole bunch of
- security checks, as was her television crew. But by October the contacts
- had decreased. Her contract to do the documentary expired, and all she had
- was the name of her Washington contact. In March 1984, she spoke with this
- man who told her that there would be further delays because of the 1984
- presidential election. Five years later, Bill Moore gave this explanation
- of this bizarre episode:
-
- Quoting Moore: "In early 1983, I became aware that Rick Doty was involved
- with a team of several others, including one fellow from Denver, and at
- least one who is working out of Washington, D.C., in playing an elaborate
- disinformation scheme against Howe."
-
- According to Moore, the episode was a counter-intelligence sting operation,
- part of the wall of disinformation intended to confuse the Bennewitz issue
- and to call his credibility into question. "Because of Howe's interest in
- Bennewitz's work," Moore said, quoting again, "certain elements within the
- intelligence community were concerned that the story of his having
- intercepted low-frequencey, electro-magnetic emissions from the Coyote
- Canyon area of the Kirtland-Sandia complex would end up as part of a
- feature film. Since this, in turn, might influence others - possibly the
- Russians - to attempt similar experiments, someone in a control position
- apparently felt that it had to be stopped before it got out of hand." Moore
- said, quoting again, "The government seemed hell-bent on severing the ties
- that existed between Howe and HBO."
-
- In his conversation with Howe, Doty had referred to an organization called
- 'MJ-12', which he insisted was short for 'Majority 12', a policy-making
- body consisting of a dozen high-ranking government scientists, military
- officers and intelligence officials. This was not the first time an 'MJ-12'
- had been mentioned in what purported to be an official document. Earlier,
- Doty had showed Moore a supposed AFOSI teletype stamped 'Secret' and dated
- November 17th, 1980. After discussing several alleged UFO films, the
- document concludes with a brief discussion of how official agencies deal
- with UFO data under the rubric of 'Project Aquarius'. It notes, quoting,
- "Results of Project Aquarius are still classified 'Top Secret' with no
- dissemination outside official intelligence channels and with restricted
- access to MJ-12." MJ-12 is not defined or explained.
-
- In October, 1988, events took a farcical turn with the broadcast of a
- two-hour documentary - using the word 'documentary' in the loosest possible
- sense - called "UFO Cover-up: Live." Falcon, and another bird, Condor -
- their faces shaded, their voices altered - related the same tales with
- which they had regaled Moore and Shandera. The show, almost universally
- judged a laughable embarrassment, was most remembered for the informants'
- statement that the aliens favoured ancient Tibetan music and strawberry
- ice-cream...
-
-